Bda20303 Chapter 1-Gear System
Bda20303 Chapter 1-Gear System
=
Where
1
speed oI driver gear
2
speed oI driven gear
D
1
pitch diameter oI driver gear
D
2
pitch diameter oI driven gear
ence, gear ratio, n;
1
2
2
1
2
1
1
2
= = = =
N
N
D
D
3
Where N
1
number teeth oI driver gear
N
2
number teeth oI driven gear
1
angular acceleration oI driver gear
2
angular acceleration oI driven gear
Driver gear
Driven gear
1.5 Gear Train
Gear trains consist oI two or more gears Ior the purpose oI transmitting motion Irom one
axis to another.
Simple Gear Train is the most common oI the gear train is the gear pair connecting
parallel shaIts. The teeth oI this type can be spur, helical or herringbone. The angular velocity is
simply the reverse oI the tooth ratio. The main limitation oI a simple gear train is that the
maximum speed change ratio is 10:1. or larger ratio, large sizes oI gear trains are required; this
may result in an imbalance oI strength and wear capacities oI the end gears.
The sprockets and chain in the bicycle is an example oI simple gear train. When the
paddle is pushed, the Iront gear is turned and that meshes with the links in the chain. The chain
moves and meshes with the links in the rear gear that is attached to the rear wheel. This enables
the bicycle to move.
Compound Gear Train is used Ior large velocities, compound arrangement is preIerred.
Two keys are keyed to a single shaIt. A double reduction train can be arranged to have its input
and output shaIts in a line, by choosing equal center distance Ior gears and pinions.
Gear trains are used in representing the phases oI moon on a watch or clock dial. It is also
used Ior driving a conventional two-disk lunar phase display oII the day-oI-the-week shaIt oI the
calendar.
:re 7 (a) Smple ear tra3 (b) C4mp4:3/ ear tra3
When a gear train is complex (consist oI many gear sets), it is important Ior the designer
to identiIy the rotation oI the driver and the Iinal driven gear respectively. owever, there is a
simple Iormula to determine the rotation oI each successive gear in a gear train.
:re 8: etw4rk ear sh4rt
A ear trai3 may have several drivers and several driven gears. When gear A turns once
clockwise, gear B turns 4 times counter-clockwise and gear turns once clockwise. ence gear
B does not change the speed oI Irom what it would have been iI geared directly to gear A, but
it changes its direction Irom counterclockwise to clockwise.
:re 9: O// 3:mber 4f mat3 ear
'or an ODD number oI mating gears, the rotation oI Driven gear is the SAME as Driver Gear.
:re 1: Eve3 3:mber 4f mat3 ear
'or an EJE number oI mating gears, the rotation oI Driven gear is REJERSE oI Driver
Gear.
Another classiIication oI gear train is called Reverted Gear Train and Epicyclic Gear Train.
1.6 Gear Efficiency
Gear eIIiciency is deIined as the ratio oI Output Power Irom Driven Gear to the Input
Power Irom Driver Gear. Gear eIIiciency measures how eIIicient a gear system is to transmit
power. igh value oI gear eIIiciency reIlects a more eIIicient gear system. Power loss in a gear
system may come Irom sources like Iriction, slip, backlash and so on.
rom Power, % P = , then
Gear EIIiciency, 3
%
%
%
%
P
P
G
1
2
1 1
2 2
1
2
2 1 ,
= = =
g
Where
1
P Input power Irom driver gear
2
P Output power Irom driven gear
3 Gear ratio
II the 0 . 1 =
G
g , thus the torque at driver gear
1
% is;
2 1
3% % =
II the 0 . 1 =
G
g , thus the torque at driver gear
1
% is;
2 1 ,
2
1
=
G
3%
%
g
1.7 Power Transmission in a Gear Train System
In a gear train system, power loss normally happen in the bearing and gear due to Iriction
and loading imposed on it and also power loss in overcoming shaIt inertia. onsider a gear train
consists oI two sets oI gear reducing arrangement. A motor is attached to the system with
m
I is
the moment oI inertia oI motor shaIt,
%
I is moment oI inertia oI middle shaIt and
G
I is the
moment oI inertia oI hoist which acts as the load oI the system. Gear ratio and gear eIIiciency oI
gear set 1-2 is
2 / 1
3 and
2 / 1 G
g , between gear set 3-4 is
4 / 3
3 and
4 / 3 G
g respectively. Let;
m
% Torque oI motor
G
% Torque oI hoist
= I %
:re 11: ree b4/y /aram
Assume clockwise direction as positive value.
4r (A)
m m m
I % % =
1
........................ (1)
4r (B)
% %
I % % =
3 2
......................... (2)
Since there is gear mating between gear 1 and 2, thus, must include in the analysis its own gear
ratio and gear eIIiciency, and relate it to the inertia oI middle shaIt,
%
I .
Previously,
2 / 1
1
2
2 / 1
3
%
%
G
= g , thus it Iollows that
2 / 1
1 2 / 1
2
3
%
%
G
g
= ............................... (3)
4r (C)
G G G
I % % % =
4
............................. (4)
also
4 / 3
4 / 3 3
4
3
%
%
G
g
= ..............................(5)
Hoist
Using power, , % P = power transIer to each gear component is;
a) !4wer tra3sfer by the m4t4r
m m m
% P =
b) !4wer at ear 1
m m m m m
I % % P = =
1 1
c) !4wer at ear 2
2 / 1 1 2 G
P P g =
/) !4wer at ear 3
% % % %
I % % P = =
2 3 3
e) !4wer at ear 4
4 / 3 3 4 G
P P g =
f) !4wer at h4st
G G G G G G
I % % % P = =
4
) Overall p4wer tra3sfer effce3cy,
g
m
G
P
P
= g
Thus iI Iriction torque,
% eIIect is neglected,
This concludes that
4 / 3 2 / 1 G G
%
G
m
%
m
G
P
P
P
P
P
P
g g g - =
'
+
'
'
+
'
= =
Also;
4 / 3 2 / 1
3 3
%
%
m
G
= g
1.8 Equivalent Moment of Inertia,
equi;
I
onsider a simple gear system as igure below. In order Ior the driver gear A to start
rotate, it must have enough torque to overcome its own inertia,
I
I % =
ReIer
= =
Thus,
3 I % =
2. Gear eIIiciency is related to power and thus torque oI the mating gears, thus
G
%
3 %
P
P
= = g
3. ThereIore, torque at A, to accelerate
I
G
G
G
G
3 I 3 3 I
3
I 3 %
%
g
g
2
= = = =
4. ThereIore total torque at A to accelerate
I and
I is
%%
% I % =
%%
3 I
I %
g
|
=
2
, Or in general Iorm,
equi; %%
I % = (reIerred to motor side)
Thus
'
+
'
=
G
equi;
3 I
I I
g
2
The derivation oI
equi;
I oI this simple gear system can be extended to a double set oI gear
reducing problem as in section 1.7. By neglecting the Iriction torque eIIect,
% , thus,
) )( (
) ( ) ( ) (
4 / 3 , 2 / 1 ,
2
4 / 3
2
2 / 1
2 / 1 ,
2
2 / 1
G G
G
G
%
m equi;
3 3 I 3 I
I I
g g g
=
Driven gear Driver gear
A
1.9 Gear Train Applications (Solved Problem)
Example 1(1ake3 fr4m R4sla3, Che' Abas, Y:3:s (21), U1M)
A motor is accelerating a 250 kg load with acceleration oI 1.2 m/s
2
through a gear system as
shown below. The rope that carries the load are encircled on a hoist with diameter 1.2m.Gear Ior
the hoist`s shaIt has 200 teeth, gear Ior motor shaIt has 20 teeth. Gear eIIiciency is 90. Mass
and radius oI gyration oI each shaIt is as below;
Mass (kg) Radius oI gyration (mm)
Motor shaIt 250 100
oist shaIt 1100 500
alculate the torque oI the motor needed to bring up the load with acceleration 1.2 m/s
2
. eglect
Iriction eIIect.
:re 13: Cear system attache/ t4 h4st
S4l:t43
Total torque at motor to bring up load
2 1 total
% % % =
Where
1
% Torque to overcome equivalent inertia (reIer to motor side).
2
% Torque to accelerate the load through gear system
a) C43s/er f4r
1
%
rom
G
G
equi;
3 I
I I
g
2
=
Thus
kgm
2
G
I oist shaIt inertia
275 5 . 0 1100
2
= =
G
I kgm
2
Dia 1.2 m
Hoist
Gear ratio, 1 . 0
200
20
2
1
= = =
N
N
3
Put into
55 . 5
9 . 0
1 . 0 275
5 . 2
2
=
=
equi;
I kgm
2
Acceleration oI hoist,
G G G
r a =
Thus 2
6 . 0
2 . 1
= =
G
rad/s
rom the gear ratio, angular acceleration oI motor, 20
1 . 0
2
= = =
3
G
m
rad/s
ow torque due to equivalent inertia,
m equi;
I % =
1
1 . 111 ) 20 ( 55 . 5
1
= =
% m.
b) C43s/er f4r
2
%
rom ewton 2
nd
Law,
= ma F
N F
a F
a F
5 . 2752
2 . 1 81 . 9 250 250
250 250
=
= =
=
Then, torque at hoist
5 . 1651 6 . 0 5 . 2752 = = = Fr %
G
m
But due to gear eIIiciency (since the hoist shaIt is connected to the gear system), torque to
accelerate the load,
5 . 183
9 . 0
1 . 0 5 . 1651
2 / 1 ,
2 / 1
2
= = =
G
G
3 %
%
g
m
Then total torque reIerred to motor side is;
5 . 183 1 . 111
2 1
=
=
total
total
%
% % %
6 . 294 =
total
% Nm
:re 14: ree b4/y /aram 4f h4st a3/ l4a/
250g
a
T
G
250 kg
r
oist
Example 2(1ake3 fr4m R4sla3, Che' Abas, Y:3:s, (21), U1M)
igure 12 below shows a motor used to accelerate a hoist through two sets oI gear reducing
system. Moment oI inertia Ior the motor shaIt is 5 kgm
2
, middle shaIt is 40 kgm
2
and hoist shaIt
is 500 kgm
2.
Gear ratio Ior gear set 1 and 2 is 1/3.5 while Ior gear set 3 and 4 is 1/ 4.5. Gear
eIIiciency Ior both gear set is 90. By neglecting the Iriction eIIect, Iind the total torque
required by the motor to accelerate the load oI 6 tones at acceleration oI 0.4 m/s
2
.
:re 15: L4a/3 system 43 ear
S4l:t43
Given that
I 5 kgm
2
, 40 =
%
I kgm
2
,
G
I 500 kgm
2
,
5 . 3
1
2 / 1
= 3 ,
5 . 4
1
4 / 3
= 3 , 9 . 0 =
G
g
eglect Iriction eIIect.
Total torque required Ior the motor is
2 1 total
% % % =
Where
1
% Torque to overcome equivalent inertia (reIer to motor side).
2
% Torque to accelerate the load through gear system
a) C43s/er f4r
1
%
Recall that
m equi;
I % =
1
, but Ior two set oI gear system with Iriction eIIect is neglected,
) )( (
) ( ) ( ) (
4 / 3 , 2 / 1 ,
2
4 / 3
2
2 / 1
2 / 1 ,
2
2 / 1
G G
G
G
%
m equi;
3 3 I 3 I
I I
g g g
=
Nm I
equi;
116 . 11
) 9 . 0 )( 9 . 0 (
)
5 . 4
1
( )
5 . 3
1
( 500
9 . 0
)
5 . 3
1
( 40
5
2 2 2
= =
Diameter 1.2 m
Hoist
rom question, given that, 4 . 0 =
G
a m/s
2
, thus;
6 . 0
4 . 0
= =
G
G
G
r
a
6667 . 0 =
G
rad/s
2
rom gear ratio,
75 . 15
1
5 . 3
1
5 . 4
1
= - = - =
m
%
%
G
m
G
Thus,
G m
75 . 15 =
5 . 10 6667 . 0 75 . 15 = =
m
rad/s
2
Thus, 5 . 10 116 . 11
1
= =
m equi; m
I %
72 . 116
1
=
% m.
It is known that
G
% reIerred to motor side will be denoted as
2
% and is related by
4 / 3 , 2 / 1 ,
4 / 3 2 / 1
2
G G
G
3 3 %
%
g g
=
6 . 889
9 . 0 9 . 0
5 . 4
1
5 . 3
1
349 . 11
2
= =
% m
Thus total torque at motor required is
2 1 total
% % % =
6 . 889 72 . 116 =
total
%
32 . 1006 =
total
% Nm.
4500g
1
a
4500 kg
oist
6000g
6000 kg
2
a
:re 1: L4a/3 BD
b) C43s/er f4r
2
% 3 :re 13;
rom ewton 2
nd
Law, ma F =
a F 4500 4500
1
=
42345 41 . 9 4500 4500
1
= = = a F
a F 6000 6000
2
=
61260 6000
2
= = a F
Resultant torque at hoist
915 . 18
1 2
= = F F F
R
k
Thus torque at hoist
349 . 11 6 . 0 915 . 18 = = =
G R G
r F % k
Example 3(1ake3 fr4m R4sla3, Che' Abas, Y:3:s, (21), U1M)
:re 17: Cear wth 3cl3e/ l4a/3
igure 14 above shows a motor accelerating a hoist with diameter 0.9m, through two sets
oI gear reducing system. Gear ratio Ior gear 1 and 2 is 1/3.5 while Ior gear 3 and 4 is 1/ 4.5.
Moment oI inertia Ior the motor shaIt is 5 kgm
2
, middle shaIt is 20 kgm
2
and hoist shaIt is 100
kgm
2
. The rope that is encircled on the hoist must be capable to liIt up a load oI 5 tones that is
sliding on a 1 in 50 slope. riction on the slope is 1000 and the total torque at motor required to
raise the load is 1500. Use gear eIIiciency oI 90 Ior both gear set. II there is Iriction torque
eIIect on the middle shaIt, 150 =
% m. alculate the
acceleration oI the load at the above condition.
S4l:t43
or the overall gear ratio,
75 . 15
1
5 . 4
1
5 . 3
1
4 / 3 2 / 1 0
= - = = 3 3 3
Total torque required by motor to raise load
3 2 1 total
% % % % =
Where
1
% Torque to overcome equivalent inertia (reIer to motor side).
2
% Torque to accelerate the load through gear system
=
3
% Total torque to overcome Iriction eIIect.
a) C43s/er f4r
1
%
Previously,
m equi;
I % =
1
or double set oI gear reducing system,
) )( (
) ( ) ( ) (
4 / 3 , 2 / 1 ,
2
4 / 3
2
2 / 1
2 / 1 ,
2
2 / 1
G G
G
G
%
m equi;
3 3 I 3 I
I I
g g g
=
312 . 7
) 9 . 0 )( 9 . 0 (
)
5 . 4
1
( )
5 . 3
1
( 100
9 . 0
)
5 . 3
1
( 20
5
2 2 2
= =
equi;
I kgm
2
Dia 0.9 m
Hoist
rom r a = , thus,
45 . 0
a
r
a
G
G
= =
Also Irom gear ratio,
75 . 15
1
=
m
G
, thus, a
a
G m
35
45 . 0
75 . 15 75 . 15 =
'
+
'
= =
Thus a %
35 312 . 7
1
= a 92 . 255 = m
b) C43s/er f4r
2
% as 3 :re 15;
c) C43s/er f4r
3
%
riction eIIect can be grouped together to Iorm
3
% where;
4 / 3 , 2 / 1 ,
4 / 3 2 / 1
2 / 1 ,
2 / 1
3
G G
Y
G
3 3 % 3 %
%
g g g
=
33 . 110
9 . 0
5 . 4
1
5 . 3
1
800
9 . 0
5 . 3
1
150
2
3
=
'
+
'
'
+
'
'
+
'
% m
rom
3 2 1 total
% % % % =
33 . 110 876 . 69 4 . 176 92 . 255 1500 = a a
Thus 1 . 3 = a m/s
2
R
F
5000g
1
F
0
Mg sin0
r
1
hoist
:re 18: 3cl3e/ l4a/3
rom
= , ma F
ma m F F
R
= sin
1
50
1
81 . 9 5000 1000 5000
1
= a F
81 . 9 5000
1
= a F
Thus, torque to accelerate hoist
45 . 0 81 . 9 5000
1
= = a r F %
G
45 . 891 2250 = a %
G
m
Use gear eIIiciency to relate
G
% with
2
%
4 / 3 , 2 / 1 ,
4 / 3 2 / 1
2
G G
G
3 3 %
%
g g
=
876 . 69 4 . 176
2
= a %
m
1.10 'ehicle Dynamics
:re 19: Jehcle /y3amcs
or a moving vehicle as in igure 16, some oI the Iorces acting on it are;
- riction due to the vehicle`s body (aerodynamic Iriction), R
- orces due to Iriction Irom the engine to the wheel such as Iriction in bearing, shaIt,
clutch and gears,
IN%
R .
- orces due the acceleration oI the vehicle, which is called tractive Iorce,
%
F considering
no slip between the wheel and the road surIace.
We can estimate the speed oI the moving vehicle by considering the speed oI the wheel itselI.
Vehicle speed,
'
+
'
=
2
D
;
r
Example 1 (S4lve/ !r4blem)
Total mass Ior a two wheeled motorcycle including passenger is 190 kg. The engine produce
torque oI 25 m at speed oI 1800 RPM. Moment oI inertia Ior each wheel is 1.4 kgm
2
while Ior
other rotating parts in the engine is considered as 0.15 kgm
2
. The wheel`s eIIective diameter is
610 mm. II the motorcycle is moving on a road with a speed 23 km/hr at second gear, Iind
(i) Gear ratio Ior the second gear
(ii) Acceleration at speed 23 km/hr
Assume wind Iriction is 200 and gear eIIiciency is 90.
S4l:t43
Given that;
m190 kg,
total
% 25 m at N 1800 PM,
R
I 1.4 kgm
2
,
int
I 0.15 kgm
2
, D610 mm,
II ; 23 km/hr at 2
nd
gear, with R 200 ,
G
g 90.
D/2
r
F
%
R
;
Wheel
S:rface
1
st
Step - Draw ree B4/y Daram
:re 2: ree b4/y /aram
2
3/
Step
Total torque at engine,
total
%
2 1 total
% % % =
Where
1
% Torque due to equivalent inertia oI rotating parts in the engine.(reIerred to engine
side).
2
% Torque to accelerate the wheel.
3
r/
Step
onvert all measurement to SI standard.
Engine speed,
5 . 188
60
1800 2
60
2
int
= = =
x xN
rad/s
Wheel speed,
3889 . 6
3600
1000 23
/ 23 = = = hr km ; m/s
4
th
Step- Determ3e
1
%
In order to Iind gear ratio Ior second gear,
9
1
5 . 188
305 . 0
3889 . 6
int
= = =
3
R
(Where
2 D
;
R
= )
1h:s ear rat4 f4r sec43/ ear s
9
1
= 3
Equivalent moment oI inertia is
G
R
equi;
3 I
I I
g
2
int
=
1884 . 0
9 . 0
9
1
4 . 1 2
15 . 0
2
=
-
=
equi;
I kgm
2
In order to Iind
int
, use
R
and gear ratio
Engine
Gear system
Wheel
I
int
I
R
2 D
a
R
=
a
a
3
R
508 . 29
9
1
305 . 0
int
= = =
rad/s
2
Thus, a I %
equi;
508 . 29 1884 . 0
int 1
= =
a %
559 . 5
1
= m.
5
th
Step - Determ3e
2
% as 3 :re 18;
:re 21: /y3amc f4rce 43 the m4t4rcycle
rom
= , ma F
ma R F
%
=
a F
%
190 200 =
Total torque at wheel,
305 . 0 190 200 a r F %
% R
= =
a %
R
95 . 57 61 =
ReIer
R
% to motor side using gear eIIiciency
9 . 0
9
1
95 . 57 61
2
a
3 %
%
G
R
= =
g
) 154 . 7 35 . 7 (
2
a %
= m
Thus, total torque at engine
a a %
total
154 . 7 35 . 7 559 . 5 =
The acceleration at that speed is;
By solving the equation Ior the total torque above, thus
374 . 1 = a m/s
2
m190 kg
T
R
a
PROEMS-GEAR SYSTEM
1. The axes oI two parallel shaIts are to be 600mm apart approximately, and have to be
connected by spur gear, having a circular pitch oI 30 mm. II gear A rotate at 200 rpm and
gear B rotate at 600 rpm, Iind the number oI teeth on each gear.
2. igure below showed a motor used to accelerate a hoist through a set oI gear system.
Gear Ior the hoist`s shaIt has 200 teeth and gear Ior motor shaIt has 20 teeth. Gear
eIIiciency is 90 . Moment oI inertia Ior the motor shaIt is 2.5 kgm and hoist shaIt is
275 kgm. The rope that carries a 250 kg load are encircle on hoist with diameter 1.2 m.
By neglecting the Iriction, Iind
a) gear ratio,
b) equivalent moment inertia Ior a gear system,
c) the total torque required by the motor to accelerate the load at acceleration oI 1.0
m/s.
Motor
Rope
Set oI gear
Load
oist
22
3 The diagram above shows a gear train composed oI three gears. Gear A revolves at 60
revs/min in a clockwise direction.
GEAR A GEAR B GEAR
20 TEET 60 TEET 10 TEET
a) What is the output in revolutions per minute at Gear
b) In what direction does Gear revolve
| 120 rpm, clockwise |