Effects of Season and Weather On Blastomycosis in Dogs: Northern Wisconsin, USA
Effects of Season and Weather On Blastomycosis in Dogs: Northern Wisconsin, USA
Dogs and humans acquire Blastomyces dermatitidis infections from the same incom-
pletely defined habitat. Studies of blastomycosis cases have not consistently demon-
strated seasonality or significant antecedent climate effects. To determine the distribution
of disease by season, we studied over 18 years 219 dogs with blastomycosis from a sin-
gle veterinary practice in Northern Wisconsin. The 202 Vilas County dog addresses were
compared to 200 random-number selected addresses from the practice registry. Street
addresses were geocoded and mapped using ArcGIS, including ratio of cases/random
addresses to construct a control chart. Stepwise and linear regression was used to model
case counts by season and by 6 month warm (April–September) and cold periods, using
lagged local weather data. The geographic distribution of cases was found to be similar
regardless of season and time period, and no season exceeded control chart limits. Seasonal
distribution of cases was; winter (n ⫽ 53, 24%), spring (39, 18%), summer (79, 36%),
fall (48, 22%), p ⫽ 0.002. When cases were considered by 6-month warm/cold periods,
67% of variation is explained by the total precipitation which occurred two periods prior,
and lower average temperature, but higher maximum temperature one period prior
(p ⫽ 0.000). Weather parameters along with fixed and variable environmental factors likely
determine the occurrence of B. dermatitidis, perhaps as part of a ‘grow and tolerate
change’ model.
Keywords Blastomyces dermatitidis, blastomycosis, fungal ecology, dog, mycoses,
weather
postulates that soil water storage and El Niño activity in county is forested, most commonly with mature upland
the prior 3 years, and absolute air humidity the year before mixed forest (a mixture of needleleaf, especially Pinus
case incidence explains 49% of the yearly variance in an strobus, Pinus resinosa, and Abies balsamea, and broad-
area of Brazil [14]. Penicillium marneffei, an opportunistic leaf, especially Betula, Populus and Acer saccharum trees
dimorphic fungus of Southeast Asia, is associated with soil taller than 9.1 m) with the balance composed largely of
exposure during rainy seasons and with burrowing bamboo waterways, including approximately 3,710 km of com-
rats [15]. bined lake, river and stream shorelines. Cases of blasto-
The precise relationship of climatic factors, if any, to mycosis in dogs from this area have been associated with
period’), the best-fit model explained 67% of the variation mapped by season. This suggests the presence, in these
(p ⬍ 0.001 for the model and the three variables) and has areas, of some relatively fixed environmental factors that
the following equation, i.e., number of new cases in 6 are important in the ecology of Blastomyces dermatitidis.
month period ⫽ 0.967 (mean maximum temperature one These presumably include two previously identified asso-
period prior) – 0.907 (mean average temperature one period ciations with Northern Wisconsin blastomycosis case
prior) ⫹ 0.554 (total precipitation two periods prior) – addresses, i.e., sandy soils and relatively low elevation
13.7. Figure 4 illustrates the predicted vs. actual cases waterways [28,29]. This study also reveals interesting
by 6 month blocks during this time period. associations with weather parameters prior to blastomyco-
sis diagnosis.
This investigation has several limitations. It is a retrospec-
Discussion tive study of moderate sample size in a single geographic
In this highly endemic area, the home-site geographic dis- location that may not be representative of other populations.
tribution and new case occurrences of blastomycosis in We were also limited to the weather parameters recorded
dogs have remained consistent over 18 years. The geo- by the local weather station. Detailed histories of the hab-
graphic distribution of these cases is also similar when its of these dogs were not obtained except as reported for
the first 3 years of the study [18]. It was not possible to
ascertain the precise onset dates of symptoms in these dogs
and the incubation period of Blastomyces dermatitidis
(sometimes regarded as 5–12 weeks) is variable and not
known with certainty [32]. There is no evidence to date
that time from exposure to diagnosis in dogs should vary
by season.
The seasonal distribution of our cases (summer/fall
predominant) differs somewhat from that of the recent
human series of Light et al. [23] (fall/winter predominant),
even when cases were adjusted one month previous to
onset. In addition, it differed from the uniform seasonal
distribution of our own human case series from the same
Fig. 2 Aggregate monthly distribution of dog blastomycosis cases, by area as the present report [24]. It is unclear whether our
month of diagnosis, December–November, years 1990–2008. results reflect a difference in geographic location in the
© 2011 ISHAM, Medical Mycology, 49, 49–55
Blastomycosis and weather 53
former case, or differences in outdoor exposures and hab- case numbers. While this best-fit model only directly cor-
its, such as sniffing and digging by dogs, compared to relates with case occurrences, one might suggest that it
humans, in both cases. The timing of the upswing of dog indirectly correlates with growth and dispersal of this
cases in our study would correlate with spring thaw and environmentally acquired fungus. If this is the case, the
presumed increase in outdoor recreational open waterway latter two parameters of the model suggest positive effects
and other exposures. Indeed, summer-diagnosed cases of more extreme temperature rises about a relatively cool
resided closer to waterways. The later spring thaw in time period, consistent with the hypothesis that Blasto-
Canada may partially explain the delayed case peak of myces dermatitidis is favored by such an environmental
Light et al. [23], compared to our study. The May–October change [8].
predominance of cases in our study is similar to that of a This hypothesis fits with previous findings related to
previous Wisconsin study [29] using similar date of diag- blastomycosis and the etiologic fungus in this area
nosis monthly assignment, without the second peak in including sandy soils [28] and close proximity to water-
November and December that they observed. The major ways [18]. Sandy soils are more prone to daily tempera-
peak in a Louisiana, USA dog series [22] occurred in ture extremes due to changes in air temperature and
August–October, perhaps partly reflecting climate differ- sunlight. They also dry out quickly following rainfall and
ences from Wisconsin. are prone to wet-dry cycles. These daily temperature and
When warm vs cold weather 6-month time periods moisture changes would be more extreme where the for-
were the unit of analysis, increased moisture on average est canopy is open due to waterways. Thus, weather-
of 1 year prior to diagnosis, and lower average tempera- induced effects on soil would likely be most pronounced
ture, but higher maximum temperature on average of in habitats previously associated with B. dermatitidis in
6 months prior to diagnosis were associated with increased this region.
10 Proctor ME, Klein BS, Jones JM, Davis JP. Cluster of pulmonary 24 Baumgardner DJ, Baeseman ZJ, Schreiber A. Geographic distribution
blastomycosis in a rural community: evidence for multiple high-risk of human blastomycosis by season in northern Wisconsin. Wis Med J
environmental foci following a sustained period of diminished pre- 2008; 107: 339–340.
cipitation. Mycopathologia 2002; 153: 113–120. 25 Sarosi GA, Eckman MR, Davies SF, Laskey WK. Canine blastomycosis
11 Blondin N, Baumgardner DJ, Moore GE, Glickman LT. Blastomycosis in as a harbinger of human disease. Ann Intern Med 1979; 91: 733–735.
indoor cats: suburban Chicago, Illinois, USA. Mycopathologia 2007; 26 MacDonald PDM, Langley RL, Gerkin SR, Torok MR, MacCormack
163: 59–66. JN. Human and canine pulmonary blastomycosis, North Carolina,
12 Baumgardner DJ. Commentary: environmental determinants of dimor- 2001–2002. Emerg Infect Dis 2006; 12: 1242–1244.
phic systemic mycoses – the macro and the micro. Int J Epidemiol 27 Baumgardner DJ, Paretsky DP. Blastomycosis: more evidence for
2009; 38: 1649–1650. exposure near one’s domicile. Wis Med J 2001; 100: 43–45.